National Survivor Study Learnings

Milestones on a Learning Journey

The National Survivor Study is designed to produce two significant bodies of research. One is the more obvious: What we learn from survivors about the specific topics the study is examining. The second is equally significant. We are learning from the unique design of this study, which aims to include survivors in every step of the process, from what questions get asked in the formal study to who facilitates focus groups to dig deeper on certain issues. We are learning what works and what doesn’t toward the end goal of meaningfully including survivors in this study as not just research subjects, but participants in the research process and the decisions about what to do with what we learn.

 

Read the Blog

“To really do community-based, participatory research well, it takes a lot of time, and you don’t always know exactly where you’re going or what it’s going to look like. To be responsive, you have to listen seriously to the people you are prioritizing as experts, which requires you to make changes you didn’t envision. It’s both the right thing and the smartest thing to do for our work.”

– Lara Powers, Senior Advisor, Survivor Engagement, Polaris

Learnings from Expert Survivors

There’s help when you first get out but there’s no long-term support.

  • In the immediate aftermath of trafficking, emergency services are available for certain groups, when survivors face legal, mental health and financial challenges, it’s a lot harder to get help. 
  • For men and boys, even immediate, emergency services are hard to come by.

“It’s almost like you graduate, you’re out in the world and you’re on your own. … The help only goes for a year. After a year, you’re basically on your own. There is no follow-up. I understand maybe there’s a lot other survivors that need help – but I feel there is no long-term [support].”

– Human trafficking survivor


There are still incredible barriers to even emergency services for some groups.

  • Fear of deportation keeps many immigrants from seeking help.
  • Existing services are not always trauma-informed, appropriate or in the right languages.
  • There are far more services available for women and girls than for men and boys.

“The first challenge out of my trafficking situation was shelter, and especially for me because I am a transgender, I was put into a male shelter where I wasn’t feeling comfortable. I ended up leaving the shelter and going into homelessness. You’re out from one situation but you’re put in another situation which is bad in a different way.”

– Human trafficking survivor


There a few very specific short-term needs that don’t get a lot of attention.

  • People often don’t have official documents required to access services. 
  • Particularly in rural areas, transportation is a huge problem. 
  • Survivors may not even know how to drive, let alone have a way to get to help. 

“It seems really simple but make sure they have access to their Social Security number. Their birth certificate. A government ID. When I got out, I didn’t know what a Social Security number was.”

– Human trafficking survivor


Initial Learnings from the Project Team

Stage 1: Planning

In the first stage, the team reviewed the literature, convened stakeholders to determine the focus of the research, and created the initial study design and data collection instruments.

  • Authentic advice comes from people with authentic experience. If you want to hear it, you have to meet them where they are and be truly – not performatively – flexible. 
  • We thought we knew how to protect survivors’ privacy. They taught us to let them make their own decisions about privacy.

Stage 2: Outreach

The team developed and carried out plans for inviting individuals to participate in the study. This included reaching out to partner organizations, bringing in consultants from different communities, and developing materials that described the study and built trust among survivors.

  • There is no shortcut to outreach and no one knows how to reach everyone. Go wide. Go big. Go deep. Build in time to build trust.
  • Don’t write a script and ask for survivors to approve it. As survivors to write it – or to make what you have written better.

Stage 3: Informed Consent

Before data collection, the team made sure that each person understood what the study involved and what was being asked of them. Using in-depth phone conversations, the team clearly shared benefits and risks, building greater trust and truly informed consent.

  • Build trust into informed consent. It should not be a perfunctory process. This has meaning and allows survivors to own their participation.
  • Survivors felt empowered to control their own participation in the NSS.

Stage 4: Discussions

As part of formative data collection, these discussions brought in survivors from different communities to help frame questions for an upcoming survey. They weighed in on a variety of topics, ranging from using appropriate language to identifying needs after exiting trafficking situations.

  • Let survivors facilitate focus groups with other survivors. Let them share their truths.
  • Inviting survivors to serve as research leaders not only enhanced trust and comfort in focus group settings but also led to better data collection.

Unexpected Outcomes

Polaris not only learned these important process lessons, but we also realized that the process itself has already generated initial impact for survivors, our team, and our partners.

  • Polaris has built trust with multiple communities.
  • The process has supported survivors in connecting, healing, and developing professional skills.
  • The process has identified learnings for improving other Polaris and anti-trafficking efforts.

As we head into 2022, Polaris is deep into NSS data collection, and we look forward to publishing initial findings later this year. Stay tuned!

Additional Information

Meaningful Engagement in Research

Preliminary findings from formative group and individual discussions on the topic of meaningful research engagement.

Service Access Challenges for Survivors

Preliminary findings from formative group and individual discussions on the topic of challenges that survivors encounter in trying to access services.

Milestones on a Learning Journey

Reflections and lessons learned from the NSS project team on trying to implement a community engaged, survivor centered study.

Need help? Polaris operates the U.S. National Human Trafficking Hotline.